Cookies For All Occasions


NYC Based Cookie Company


Creating Edible Art to Bring People Joy.

The Royal Sifting Company and its master baker Melinda are dedicated to creating smiles every time someone bites into one of our cookies.

Our products are made with premium organic ingredients locally sourced from NY small farms. Our imported ingredients such as vanillas and chocolates are sourced from certified organic and fair-trade purveyors. We use the highest quality organic sugars and never use corn syrup, preservatives, or artificial ingredients.

Guaranteed freshness as all orders are baked to order and heat sealed.

We are confident you will not only enjoy the beautiful designs but also the taste!

(Local pick-up in Lower Manhattan. Delivery in 5 boroughs for additional fee. NY shipping available.)


Our signature cookie was developed from one of Melinda’s favorite childhood treats…. malted milkshakes!

These sandwich cookies are filled with homemade marshmallow whip in between two malted milkshake flavored cookies and finished with sprinkles.

All organic ingredients. Contains dairy. Baked upon ordering. Heat sealed for freshness.

Malted Milkshake.

20210331_royal_sifting_co_0541.jpg

Need just a little something sweet to satisfy your craving?

These petite cookies were created just for that! Each pack contains 10 1x1.5 cookies that range from signature vanilla bean cookies to new flavors like blueberries and cream.

All organic ingredients. Contains dairy. Baked upon ordering. Heat sealed for freshness.

Petite Royals.

All custom decorated cookies are made with our signature vanilla bean sugar cookie recipe and hand decorated with vanilla royal icing. Other flavors are offered at an additional cost.

The Royal Sifting Company uses its own in house designed cookie cutters.

Each design package contains a dozen cookies and orders must be placed within 4-6 weeks in advance of ship/pick-up date.

Custom Orders.